Three Big Dummys

Song of the Day:

I Love You, You Big Dummy

This tender, sweet love song was originally written by Don Van Vliet, better known as Captain Beefheart. It’s heartwarming message of affection must have deeply effected Howard Devoto, who was moved to record it with two of his bands, first with an early version of Buzzcocks and then a fuller more, touching version with his band Magazine. He was, apparently also moved to write more lyrics – a lot more lyrics. Beefheart’s version has barely one verse but, Devoto quadrupled the lyrics and also embellished the melody a bit (to fine effect). We like all these but, we do believe we prefer the final Magazine take as the fullest expression of the song’s deep, warm-hearted message. Please enjoy all three versions as a special triple-treat Song of the Day. Let us know which you prefer in the comments, and remember, dear Imaginary Readers, we love you, you Big Dummys! Awww.

Here is the Captain’s original from his 1970 album, Lick My Decals Off, Baby: